Utica, New York, might be best known to baseball fans as the home of the Utica Blue Sox, but beyond the diamond lies a vibrant arts scene that combines historic theaters, Broadway-caliber musicals, and some of the funniest stand-up comics on tour. Whether you’re a long-time local or visiting town for a game, there’s plenty of entertainment waiting in the wings. This guide explores the local theater venues, highlights can’t-miss musicals, and introduces comedians bringing their humor to stages across the country. It’s the perfect cultural companion for every Blue Sox fan ready to take a swing at something new.
Built: 1928
Capacity: 2,963 seats
This historic theatre, with its grand Moorish design and stunning architecture, is one of the largest and most iconic venues in Central New York. It has hosted everything from Broadway touring shows to symphonies and world-famous performers.
Built: 1928
Capacity: Approximately 1,788 seats
Located just 20 minutes from Utica, this vintage theatre underwent restoration and now presents musicals, classic film screenings, and live comedy. It’s a charming destination for fans of old-school ambience with modern sound and lighting.
Established: 1913
Capacity: 100+ seats
As one of the oldest community theaters in the country, Players of Utica stages compelling dramas, comedies, and musicals produced by local talent. It’s a beloved grassroots institution known for its creative spirit.
Hadestown opened on Broadway in 2019, a reinvention of Greek myth through a folk and jazz lens. Written by Anaïs Mitchell, it tells the tragic story of Orpheus and Eurydice, underscored by haunting melodies like “Wait for Me.” The show won eight Tony Awards, including Best Musical and Best Original Score. Its poetic lyrics and innovative staging make it a standout.
Since its debut in 2002, Hairspray has celebrated body positivity and racial integration through the story of Tracy Turnblad in 1960s Baltimore. With upbeat songs like “You Can’t Stop the Beat” and “Good Morning Baltimore,” it won eight Tony Awards, including Best Musical. The show is both high-energy and socially conscious. Its colorful choreography and optimistic message are perfect for all ages.
Lin-Manuel Miranda’s groundbreaking Hamilton premiered in 2015 and uses hip-hop, R&B, and traditional Broadway elements to recount the life of Alexander Hamilton. With chart-topping songs like “My Shot” and “The Schuyler Sisters,” it earned 11 Tony Awards and a Pulitzer Prize. The musical became a cultural phenomenon and broke box office records across North America. It continues to redefine what musical theatre can be.
A feel-good celebration of love, family, and friendship, Mamma Mia first graced Broadway in 2001 and features ABBA’s timeless hits. The story centers around Sophie, a bride-to-be who invites three men who could be her father to her Greek island wedding. With infectious songs like “Dancing Queen” and “Take a Chance on Me,” it’s earned over $2 billion globally. It’s an ideal escape filled with sunshine and sequins.
Premiering in 1975 and revived in 1996, Chicago is a sassy satire of celebrity, corruption, and justice set to a jazzy score. With timeless songs like “All That Jazz” and “Razzle Dazzle,” it holds the record as Broadway’s longest-running revival. The show has won six Tony Awards and a Grammy for Best Musical Show Album. Its Fosse-inspired choreography and sultry storytelling never lose appeal.
Not a traditional musical, Blue Man Group combines music, performance art, and humor into an unforgettable sensory experience. Since its Off-Broadway debut in 1991, the act has expanded globally and played to over 35 million fans. With no spoken dialogue, it appeals universally through visual spectacle and percussive rhythms. It’s equal parts concert and comedy.
Six gives the six wives of Henry VIII a voice—and a beat—with this electrifying pop concert-style musical. Debuting in the UK in 2017 and arriving on Broadway in 2021, the show earned two Tony Awards for Best Original Score and Costume Design. Songs like “Ex-Wives” and “Don’t Lose Ur Head” reimagine Tudor drama as modern empowerment. It’s fast, fierce, and feminist.
Based on Tim Burton’s 1988 film, Beetlejuice made its Broadway debut in 2019. It features an irreverent tone, fourth-wall-breaking humor, and catchy songs like “Say My Name” and “Dead Mom.” Nominated for eight Tony Awards, the show’s visual spectacle and eccentric characters have developed a cult following. It’s the perfect blend of spooky and hilarious.
One of the most beloved musicals of all time, Les Misérables premiered on Broadway in 1987 and is based on Victor Hugo’s novel of revolution, sacrifice, and redemption. Featuring powerful ballads like “On My Own” and “Bring Him Home,” the show won eight Tony Awards. It has been performed in 44 countries and 22 languages. Its emotional gravitas and sweeping score remain timeless.
Serving as a prequel to The Wizard of Oz, Wicked explores the unlikely friendship between Elphaba and Glinda. Since its 2003 Broadway debut, it has won three Tony Awards and grossed over $1 billion in New York alone. Standout songs include “Defying Gravity” and “For Good.” The show’s magical visuals and themes of identity and acceptance resonate strongly with all generations.
New to Broadway in 2023, Shucked is a comedy-musical hybrid set in a small town reliant on its corn crop. With music by country stars Brandy Clark and Shane McAnally, and a book by Robert Horn, the show balances heartfelt storytelling and rural absurdity. It won the Tony for Best Featured Actor and earned praise for its originality. Its homespun charm and wit make it a sleeper hit.
Known for his squeaky-clean and relatable comedy, Jim Gaffigan rose to fame with his “Hot Pockets” routine. He’s been nominated for several Grammy Awards and has headlined specials on Netflix, Comedy Central, and Amazon Prime. Gaffigan has sold out iconic venues like Radio City Music Hall. His humor often centers on food, parenting, and everyday absurdities.
Taylor Tomlinson’s introspective and witty stand-up has made her one of comedy’s brightest new stars. Her Netflix specials, Quarter-Life Crisis and Look at You, earned critical acclaim for tackling themes like mental health, faith, and dating. She was named one of Time’s 100 Most Influential People in 2022. Her self-aware humor connects deeply with millennial and Gen Z audiences.
Gabriel “Fluffy” Iglesias is a storytelling comic known for his animated voice work and relatable material about family, food, and culture. He’s one of the few comedians to sell out Dodger Stadium and has released multiple Netflix and Comedy Central specials. Iglesias’s warmth and charisma transcend language and background. He blends impressions and personal anecdotes into a style all his own.
Matt Rife first gained attention through his appearances on MTV’s Wild ’N Out and has exploded in popularity thanks to viral stand-up clips. His comedy blends physical humor, quick-witted crowd interactions, and commentary on modern dating. He now sells out shows nationwide and appeals strongly to younger fans on TikTok and Instagram. Rife’s rising stardom marks him as one of comedy’s fresh new faces.
No matter your taste—from the rebellious anthems of Six to the infectious melodies of Mamma Mia, or the laughs brought by Gabriel Iglesias—TicketSmarter has your next night out covered. Blue Sox fans can enjoy 5% off their ticket purchases to any event featured in this guide by using promo code BLUESOX5 at checkout. Whether you’re in the mood for Broadway magic or gut-busting comedy, it’s never been easier to support the arts and save.
The Blue Sox may dominate the diamond, but Utica’s cultural scene is just as rich and exciting. With historic venues like Stanley Theatre hosting award-winning musicals and today’s top comedians touring New York State, fans have front-row access to world-class entertainment. Whether you’re singing along with Hamilton, laughing with Taylor Tomlinson, or tapping your toes to Shucked, there’s always a reason to get out and experience something live. So grab your tickets, bring a friend, and let the arts take you out to the theatre.
Become a member of the Blue Sox community today by checking us out on our social media platforms listed below!
#BlueSoxNation
Site Developed By Brockett Creative Group
Copyright © Utica Blue Sox. All rights reserved.